Tim Stewart

Tim Stewart, Pastor

Tim has been our pastor since 1990.  A native of Bristol, VA, he earned a BA in Biblical Studies from Belhaven College (Jackson, MS) in 1975.  He attended Trinity Evangelical Divinity School (Deerfield, IL) from 1975 - 1978.  In 1986, Tim graduated with an M.Div. from Columbia Theological Seminary (Decatur, GA).  In 2014, Tim earned a doctorate in Worship Studies from the Robert E. Webber Institute for Worship Studies in Jacksonville, FL.

Joseph Mayes

Joseph Mayes, Director of Worship Arts

Joseph began his work at Burnt Store in June 2017. With a lifelong love of both music and the church, Joseph earned a Bachelor of Arts in Music from Averett University, in Danville, Virginia, and a Master of Arts in Church Music from Southeastern Seminary, in Wake Forest, North Carolina. A native of Virginia, Joseph has served churches in Virginia, Georgia, and Florida. His past work includes serving large United Methodist Churches, one outside of Atlanta and the other on the Georgia coast. After moving to Florida, Joseph became Minister of Music at Community Presbyterian in Englewood, where his wife is the Pastor.

Robin Milona

Robin Milona, Office Administrator

Robin provides secretarial assistance to the pastors, other staff, session members, church committees and organizations; answers phones and email, maintains data bases, distributes mail, prepares bulletins and newsletters, orders supplies, maintains equipment and completes any other duties upon request.

Bill Holbrook

Bill Holbrook, Facilities Manager

Joe Potts

Joe Potts, Treasurer

Joe graduated from Lutheran High School in St. Louis and then Missouri University in Columbia from which he received a BS in Electrical Engineering.  After college, Joe was employed by the General Telephone Company (GTE).  While with GTE, he enrolled in school again, this time receiving an MBA from Pepperdine University in California.  GTE promoted Joe twelve times over the 34 years he was in their employ.  These promotions caused his family to experience inter-state moves each time.  

Joyce Lehr

Joyce Lehr, Receptionist

Ext 0    
Eric Jordan

Eric Jordan, Praise Team Director

Eric has been leadng the music and singing in our contemporary service since 2011. With no formal musical training, Eric uses the experience of over twenty years of praise and worship team participation and a leaning on the Spirit to find the blend of music each week that helps bring the congregation into the 

Copyright 2018, Burnt Store Presbyterian Church (USA) of Punta Gorda, Florida, Inc.

11330 Burnt Store Road - Punta Gorda - Florida - 33955
Phone: (941) 639-0001     Fax: (941) 639-1069
Email:     Website:
Office Hours
Mon - Thurs 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM  /  Friday 9:00 AM - 12:00 PM
Sunday Services
Traditional: 8:15 AM & 11:00 AM, Contemporary: 9:40 AM